Over-Trading: How to Donate Your Balance to the Broker

Let me tell you something I’ve learned after fifteen years of watching traders blow accounts with the efficiency of a pyromaniac at a petrol station: over-trading isn’t a market problem. It’s a you problem.

I once knew a lad named Marcus. Decent bloke, sharp mind, worked in IT. One Tuesday, he opened a forex account with £8,000. By Friday, he was down to £347. When I asked him what happened, he pulled up his trading journal—or rather, what I can only describe as a manifesto of financial self-harm. 127 trades in four days.

One hundred and twenty-seven. I had to ask him to repeat it because I thought he was having a stroke.

“The market was moving,” he explained, as if that was a legitimate justification for treating his brokerage account like a slot machine in Piccadilly.

Welcome to over-trading, folks. The gift that keeps on giving—directly to your broker’s bonus pool.

The Illusion of Activity

Here’s the thing about trading psychology that nobody wants to admit: moving is not progress. But try telling that to the dopamine-addicted retail trader glued to a one-minute chart at 3 AM, convinced that the next big move is just one more trade away.

Over-trading stems from a beautifully delusional place: the belief that more activity equals more opportunity. It’s the financial equivalent of a gym bro thinking that if one scoop of protein powder is good, five scoops will make him a superhero. Spoiler alert: he’ll just throw up.

When you over-trade, you’re essentially paying your broker for the privilege of proving that your edge doesn’t exist. Every commission, every spread, every slippage—it’s a tax on your delusion. And you’re paying it voluntarily.

The statistical reality? A study by CAGR showed that traders who execute 10+ trades per day underperform traders who average 2-3 per week by a factor of roughly 3:1. But did anyone tell Marcus that? No. He was too busy chasing his fourth losing trade of the morning to read research.

The Emotional Treadmill

Let’s be honest: over-trading is emotional. It’s not logical. Logic would suggest that if your trading plan says “wait for the London close,” you wait for the London close. But logic doesn’t run the show—fear and greed do.

You’re sitting there, watching the market, and you’re bored. The setup isn’t there, but you open a position anyway because “it might work.” That’s not trading; that’s gambling with extra steps.

Then, when you lose (and you will lose), you over-trade to revenge trade your way back to profitability. Spoiler alert: that’s how £8,000 becomes £347.

I’ve seen traders enter more positions in a day than a professional money manager would in a month. Why? Because they’ve confused busyness with competence. They think their broker respects them for high turnover. Newsflash: your broker respects your trading activity the way a casino respects a drunk betting red at roulette.

The Maths Never Lies (Unfortunately)

Let’s do some back-of-the-napkin calculations, shall we?

Say you’re trading a micro account. You decide to scalp. Fifty trades per day seems reasonable to you—ambitious, but achievable. Your average spread is 1.5 pips, your average commission is 0.5 pips (depending on your broker), and you assume a breakeven win rate because you’re “really good.”

That’s 2 pips per trade against you before you even factor in slippage.

50 trades × 2 pips = 100 pips of pure friction costs per day.

On a standard lot, that’s $1,000. Per day. Every single day, you’re donating £700-£800 to your broker just for the privilege of clicking buttons frantically.

Over a month (22 trading days), that’s £15,400 in pure friction.

But you won’t break even on friction—you’ll add losing trades on top of it. Your actual losses will be double that, easy.

Now multiply that by your actual trade volume if you’re not even thinking about this before you start.

Most over-traders don’t calculate this. They should, but they don’t. It’s like asking an alcoholic to do the maths on how much they spend on booze per year. They know it’s bad; they just don’t want to know the exact number.

The Broker’s Perspective (and Why They Love You)

Here’s a beautiful bit of irony: the broker loves over-traders. They’re the bread and butter. The retail trader who scalps 50 times a day on a 1.5 pip spread is basically a vending machine of profit.

Every time you over-trade, you’re:

• Paying wider spreads
• Hitting your broker’s liquidity providers
• Creating enough volume to trigger trade execution delays
• Increasing slippage on your fills

The broker wins whether you’re right or wrong. But when you over-trade, they win faster and more often. You’re not beating the market; you’re feeding it.

How to Stop Being a Donation Machine

Right, so how do you actually stop over-trading? Here’s what actually works:

1. Use a Forex Calculator Seriously. Before each trade, plug the numbers into a position sizing calculator. If it takes longer than 10 seconds, you’re not trading it. If the math doesn’t stack, you’re not trading it. No exceptions.

2. Set Daily Trade Limits Pick a number. Stick to it. If you tell yourself “maximum 5 trades per day,” then actually do that. I know a bloke who physically locks his trading platform after five trades. Drastic? Maybe. Effective? Absolutely.

3. Create a Pre-Trade Checklist Ask yourself:

• Does this align with my trading plan?
• Can I justify the risk/reward on a calculator?
• Am I bored or genuinely seeing a setup?
• Have I already traded too much today?

4. Track Your Friction Costs Calculate what you’re actually paying in spreads and commissions. Write it down. It’s eye-opening and absolutely humbling.

5. Measure Win Rate, Not Volume Stop bragging about how many trades you took. Start tracking your actual profitability per trade. One winning trade is worth more than 47 losing ones.

The Bottom Line

Over-trading is the retail trader’s version of self-sabotage wearing a tuxedo. It feels professional, it looks active, and it’s absolutely lethal to your account.

Marcus eventually quit trading. Last I heard, he was back in IT, doing quite well. He lost £7,653 before he figured out that less really is more in this game.

Don’t be Marcus. Use a calculator. Stick to your plan. Stop donating to your broker.

Your future self will thank you.

---

Now stop reading and go do the maths on your last 20 trades. Actually do it. I’ll wait.